Folk music, folk-rock, and roots, from Colin Randall and friends.

Deja Vu, all over again—remaking CSN&Y’s classic record

CategorIes:

,

By

·

4–7 minutes

Andrew Curry writes: Over at the Salut Live Facebook group the Wandering Hearts’s new record, Deja Vu, is our Album of the Month. If you think the title sounds familiar, you’d be right. The Wandering Hearts—an English three-piece usually described as ‘Americana-folk’—have done a song-by-song remake of the record released by Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young 55 years ago.

If you’re not familiar with Wandering Hearts, they started out in London ten years ago, and have released a string of well-regarded albums since then, as well as touring with some notable artists and appearing at Nashville’s Grand Old Opry. These days they are a trio, made up of Tara Wilcox, Francesca ‘Chess’ Whiffin, and AJ Dean. I’ll get back to the Wandering Hearts’s version of the album later on, but for the moment, let’s just say that they do it pretty well.

IMG_7750

 


So let’s travel back to 1970. Deja Vu was a follow up to Crosby, Stills, and Nash’s first LP together, also called Crosby Stills & Nash. David, Steven, and Graham had all known each other before they started playing together, of course, but they’d ended up singing harmonies together at a Laurel Canyon dinner party, as you do, and realised that their voices blended well. (It might have been at Joni’s place, it might have been Mama Cass’s, accounts differ.)

It took some wheeling and dealing by Ahmet Artegun of to extract them from their various contracts (Crosby had been asked to leave the Byrds, but was still contracted), and they put their names into the band name so it couldn’t continue if any of them left.Crosby Stills & Nash was a commercial and critical success.

For reasons to do with the band sound, Ahmet Ertegun decided to pitch Neil Young into this volatile mix. Young joined for the recording of Deja Vu, which was made in studios in San Francisco and Los Angeles. The mood was darker than on the first album: David Crosby’s girlfriend had recently been killed in a car crash, and Stills and Nash had just broken up with their partners.

The four men were rarely in the studio at the same time, and focused on the individual songs they had contributed.

But they found time to criticise each other’s contributions. On Woodstock, at least by Neil Young’s account, Stills response to criticism of his vocal track was to erase it and replace it with one that he knew wasn’t as good. The tour that followed, before the band broke up, is the stuff of rock legend, with backstage fights breaking out between band members.

All the same, the record was in the Billboard 200 chart for a year and a half. My go-to guide to ‘60s and ‘70s music, The NME Book of Rock 2 from 1977, describes the result as

more eclectic [than Crosby, Stills and Nash] in its approach… One of the highlights was Stills’ Carry On, which showed Crosby and Nash’s harmonies as good as ever… [P]laying was fine throughout.

But the NME writers also noted the hippie naivété of some of the songs.

IMG_7755

From the sound of it, Wandering Hearts had a better time in the studio than CSN&Y. They recorded their version of Deja Vu over the course of a few weeks in the home studio of Michael Rault and Pearl Charles in Joshua Tree, in the Californian desert, working with Rault and Charles on the songs. The location provides the opportunity for some striking photos as well.

One of the features of the band’s work is their close vocal harmonies, and you can see why that might attract them to the work of CSN&Y. But it seems that their fondness for Deja Vu goes deeper than that: this was a record that was familiar to the band members from their respective childhoods. Tara Wilcox’s father even saw CSN&Y play Woodstock.

As AJ Dean say on the band’s website:

“The more we talked about it, the more the idea of doing it ourselves appealed. With a cover, you either have to do something so different that it becomes something new, or because you love it so much that you have to pay tribute. I think our version of Déjà Vu is something in between.”

One review described it as “a love letter” to the original. It’s certainly not a copy, more a set of revisions. One of the obvious differences is the two women’s voices in the harmonies, compared to the all-male line-up of CSN&Y.

This does lead to some curiosities. David Crosby’s Almost Cut My Hairwas recorded at a time when the length of young men’s hair was a generational fault-line. So although Tara Wilcox sings the same lyric very well, it’s more personal than political.

And in general, the Wandering Hearts’ versions of these songs are just a bit lighter, and a bit less rock-y, than the originals, even a bit more English, and for me at least that’s welcome.

CSN&Y’s Deja Vu is regarded as a classic of the era, but the harmonies are more interesting than the guitars.

You hear this clearly on Our House, written by CSN&Y’s English band member Graham Nash. The Wandering Hearts open the song out a bit, and make the most of the female harmonies, and the arrangement sits beneath the voices.

You can take tributes a bit too far, though. CSN&Y’s version of Woodstock is a long, long, way from being the best cover of Joni Mitchell’s song, drowning out the subtleties of the original in thumping four-square guitar. No-one would have blamed the Wandering Hearts if they’d decided to do something more interesting with the song.

I’ve been listening to the two recordings side by side — I even made a playlist on Spotify where I alternated the songs from the two albums while I was thinking about this piece — and the more I listened, the more I was impressed by the remake. As Seuras Og says on the Cover Me site,

Call me surprised, but this Déjà Vu knocked spots off any expectations I may have held for it.

And for me too.

—


https://cdnjs.buymeacoffee.com/1.0.0/button.prod.min.js
Feel free to ignore the donation figures suggested by Buy me a Coffee. If you'd like to support our work, just type in your own sum

~ —

And do visit our Facebook group!


Discover more from Salut! Folk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply